Last year, my mother-in-law told me I wasn’t “family enough” to be in the Christmas photos. I swallowed my pride and bit my tongue. But this year? I had a plan—and let’s just say it left her storming into my house a few days before Christmas.
If my mother-in-law, Ellen, ever wrote a memoir, it might be titled “How to Alienate Your Daughter-in-Law in Ten Easy Steps.” Honestly, it’d probably sell well, considering how many people can relate to in-law drama.
From the moment I started dating Peter, Ellen made it clear I was temporary, a fleeting accessory in her son’s life. For five years, she subtly—and sometimes not-so-subtly—pushed me to the fringes of her family.
Peter’s family loved taking photos, especially during holidays. Yet somehow, Ellen always found a way to leave me out.
“Maybe when you two actually get married, I’ll consider it,” she’d say with a smile so tight it could shatter glass.
When we did get married last year, I thought things would change. They didn’t. At the annual Christmas Eve gathering, she pulled her usual move, asking me to step aside for the family photo.
“I am family,” I protested.
Ellen’s reply? “Well, you just got married. You’re not family enough yet.”
Her words hit me like a slap, and the silence in the room was deafening. Thankfully, the rest of the family rallied behind me. Even my father-in-law, Frank, told her, “Ellen, that’s enough. Elizabeth is family.”
Peter stood by me, too. But Ellen’s reluctant inclusion of me in that year’s photo felt tainted. Her sour expression in every shot said it all.
This year, I decided to take matters into my own hands.
Use: ?fitbcheeks? to save??
A few weeks before Christmas, I sent out holiday cards for the first time in my life. The photo featured Peter, me, and his family—everyone except Ellen.
I didn’t feel the slightest bit guilty. If I wasn’t “family enough” last year, maybe this year she wasn’t.
The reaction came swiftly. One quiet morning, as I sipped coffee, I heard the screech of tires in my driveway. Moments later, Ellen stormed through the front door, her face flushed with fury, waving the holiday card in the air.
“You think this is funny?!” she bellowed. “How dare you exclude me from a family photo!”
I sipped my coffee calmly and replied, “Good morning to you too, Ellen.”
She slammed the card onto the table. “Don’t you ‘good morning’ me! When was this taken? And WHY wasn’t I included?”
I leaned back, keeping my tone even. “I thought you didn’t see me as family. You made that crystal clear last Christmas when you said I wasn’t family enough for the photo.”
“That was completely different!” she snapped. “You’re being petty and cruel, Elizabeth. Do you know how humiliating this is for me?”
“Humiliating?” I raised an eyebrow. “Imagine how I felt last year. Maybe now you understand.”
Just as she seemed ready to explode, Frank appeared in the hallway. “Ellen, that’s enough.”
Her eyes widened. “What are you doing here?”
“I helped Elizabeth with the card,” he said firmly. “Your behavior over the years has gone too far. Elizabeth is part of this family, and it’s time you start treating her that way.”
Ellen’s jaw dropped. “You’re taking her side?”
“Yes,” Frank said. “Because you’re wrong.”
Before Ellen could reply, Peter entered the room. “Mom, this has to stop. Elizabeth is my wife, and I won’t let you treat her this way anymore.”
Ellen glared at him, then at me, her voice trembling with anger. “You’d cut me off? After everything I’ve done for you?”
Peter sighed. “I don’t want to. But if you can’t respect Elizabeth, we’ll have to rethink how much time we spend with you.”
The room fell silent. For once, Ellen seemed at a loss for words.
In the weeks that followed, something shifted. Ellen’s behavior wasn’t perfect, but it improved. She invited me to tea, sought my opinion on small matters, and even gave me a compliment or two.
When Christmas Eve arrived, she surprised everyone by insisting I be in the family photo. As we gathered around the fireplace, she stood beside me, her smile—while small—seemed genuine.
It wasn’t a fairy-tale ending, but it was progress. And for now, that was enough.
